Tablet PC and Ultra-Mobile PC News, Forums, and Video Reviews  
       
 
 
 

Sunday, May 04, 2008

« Third Day of the Dragon over at OSNNMain  | Lenovo U110 Eval Arrives - My Wife Loves It! »

Stop With The Glossy, Ok?

- Warner Crocker

MeRob’s away with his kids on a camping trip this weekend, and I’m guessing when he gets back he’ll discover that he’s received one of the evaluation units of Lenovo’s IdeaPad U110, seeing that the tech blogging world seems to be unboxing and giving first looks at the new device from Lenovo. (See jkOnTheRun and Engadget to name two.) From what I’ve seen so far in terms of early reports around the web, it appears a distrubing (at least for me) trend is continuing. That trend is to make glossy screens and glossy cases ubiquitous, it seems. Apparently even the keys on the IdeaPad are glossy. I’m anxious to hear Rob’s reports about this.

Ok, folks, gloss belongs on lips not on computers, OK? I’m sure some like glossy screens. I don’t. I don’t like glossy cases either. The HP tx2051 I’m evaluating has a glosssy screen that reflects so much I can comb my hair in the reflection. The case, while not quite what I would call glossy, is a fingerprint and smudge magnet. So, it seems, is the fate of the IdeaPad U110, from what I’m reading.

What the heck is this move towards glossy everything? Is there some marketing survey out there that says customers want messy cases and unreadable screens? 

Stop with the glossy. Now.


Hardware | HP | Lenovo

5/4/2008 11:28 AM MST  

Stop With The Glossy, Ok?     Comments [12]  |  Digg This |  del.icio.us |  Citations 
Sunday, May 04, 2008 11:34:02 AM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
WOW - that must the glossy if you can see your "hair" in there... maybe you're just talking about your facial hair, I know you still have some of that left

:-)
(Gotta give the old guy a hard time every now an again)
Sunday, May 04, 2008 12:03:07 PM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
glossy screens are very good if they are treated with the proper anti-reflection coating. I love the screen of my Vaio SZ6,; the best screen I have! Sony applies a high quality coating.
everbrave
Sunday, May 04, 2008 12:03:33 PM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
In my opinion, the absolute best laptop displays on the market right now are the ones found on the Dell Latitude D630/D830 series. No gloss, high-res, and very crisp, clear images. Like you, I hate the glossy style displays and although my Toshiba tablets have them, at least they aren't as bad as most of the glossy displays I've seen.
GoodThings2Life
Sunday, May 04, 2008 12:05:46 PM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
I hate glossy screens and have always wondered why anti-reflective treatments were't applied to them (like with eyeglasses). My Lenovo X61 has a wonderfully non-glossy screen... now if only it could go a whole lot brighter for clarity outside.
Sunday, May 04, 2008 12:38:43 PM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
I like glossy screens. I constantly work under overhead lighting and reflection and glare has never been a problem for me; I just adjust the screen to the right position. The added benefit is it's easy to clean and looks much sharper.

So yeah, no problem with them here.
Antimatter
Sunday, May 04, 2008 1:25:53 PM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
Warner,

Do you find the Tx2051 to be usable with the gloss or not?

Have a good one,

~A
Amafortas
Sunday, May 04, 2008 2:33:30 PM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
Gee, Warner, I'm not sure I'm clear on your position on this one. Could you summarize and tell us how you really feel?!

I agree, btw - no gloss for me.

D.
David
Sunday, May 04, 2008 4:03:05 PM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
To be honest - working at Office Depot I do find more people attracted to the glossy screen. Once you explain that with glossy comes to problem of seeing yourself in it, people tend to understand and change their minds a bit, but they do find it to be...prettier. The same for the laptop cases. I've been showing my girlfriend tablet PCs for when she goes to college, and the one she likes the most is the TX2000 series because it's "pretty."

Also - I've never found glossy screens to be unreadable. You just have to focus your eyes to the light coming out, not the light shining on it.
Tim
Sunday, May 04, 2008 4:17:01 PM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
I much prefer glossy screens on conventional notebooks especially for watching movies or digital TV - the best I've had recently was a dell 1720 with a 1920x1200 screen (LG) - pin-sharp and extremely vibrant. By comparison a couple of Vaio Sz's that I've owned (one conventional backlight, other LED) seemed rather drab for movie watching - the anti-reflective coating is undoubtedly great for business users - not so good for watching video.

There is an argument about glossy screens not being colour accurate or for that matter, true to life (e.g. peoples faces don't actually 'glow')- but for entertainment purposes, I prefer them. Some glossy screens are better than others, e.g. I never liked the Toshiba U200, as it was very reflective and the colours were a TOO saturated.

Worse screen ever, was a M200 with the grainny screen protector removed - it was horribly reflective - against the black background of xp starting up, you might as well have been looking in a mirror.

The T2010 I'm now using seems to have a fairly conventional matte display - movies don't seem too bad either, colour accuracy seems very nice - I have a WD 320GB drive installed, with a 180GB partition just for divx movies - currently 237 of them :-)
RDX.
Monday, May 05, 2008 4:22:29 AM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
I really cant stand glossy screens. Having to adjust the viewing angle away from the ideal for my work environment so im not getting terrrible reflections just cramps my style.
Hate Hate Hate glossy. Just cant stand it. Was playing with a HP tx2000 recently and all i could see much of the time was the ceiling lights whiting out my screen.
Donald
Monday, May 05, 2008 7:58:16 AM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
Glossy screens = glare = eye strain.

If you see reflections, it makes it difficult to focus.

We have gone from glass CRTs with little gadgets on them to make them non-reflective, to non-glare LCDs, to... gloss?

This has to be a fad that will last until too many people get headaches with this gen of notebooks and gravitates to those that are non-glossy for a replacement.

Hey! If the normal replacement cycle for notebooks is 3 years, could this be a ploy to lower it to 1 year?


Personally, I hope when I need to replace my X61T (non-glossy!) that there will be a non-gloss alternative. Going from a machine I can use in full sun to one I can use only in a dark room would be rather annoying.
sfwrtr
Tuesday, May 06, 2008 9:42:30 PM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
I have no problem with glossy screen, but glossy case and keyboards are too much. I once had a laptop with glossy keyboard and after a while, the keyboard becomes looking pretty messy.
ignar
Comments are closed.


       





Copyright 2008 GottaBeMobile.com
 
     
 
     
 
     
 
     
  The vision of GottaBeMobile.com is to become the definitive source for mobile computing news, reviews, and commentary, as well as the home for the mobile community to discover and discuss these issues. When you think mobile, think GottaBeMobile.com.

The mobile computing space is one of the fastest growing and fastest changing spaces, and indeed industries worldwide. Within that constantly evolving and face paced world, GBM covers a range of spaces and technologies including Tablet PCs, UMPCs, MIDs, Ultra-portable computers, operating systems, software, natural human interfaces, accessories, mobile connectivity solutions, and other solutions that appeal to the mobile user.
     
Featured Stories
     
 
Search News

     
Latest GBM Shortcut Video Reviews and InkShows

 
News Categories
     
News Archive