Tablet PC and Ultra-Mobile PC News, Forums, and Video Reviews  
       
 
 
 

Sunday, March 02, 2008

« Motion Computing Announces The F5 Tablet PCMain  | Intel Announces Atom »

GBM InkShow: Motion Computing F5 Tablet PC Video Review

- Rob Bushway

MOV013_0001 InkShowMotion Computing has officially announced their F5 Tablet PC. The F5 is targeted for the field force vertical market. The F5 is a semi-rugged Tablet PC, positioning itself between commercial Tablet PCs like the LE1700 and more rugged Tablet PCs like Mobile Demand's T8700. It improves upon Motion's Clinical Tablet PC, the C5, by including integrated Sprint Broadband WWAN, IP54 rating, 32 GB SSD option, and an optional vehicle dock. It also features a new two-tone color scheme, which is less likely than the C5 to show dirt. It includes other features from the C5 like an integrated 2 megapixel camera, handle, RFID, optional barcode scanner, a 10.4" active digitizer screen, 1024 x 768 resolution, and a 1.2 ghz Core Solo processor. The F5 weighs 3 lbs 9 oz.

I've been fortunate enough to use the F5 the past two weeks, and have thoroughly enjoyed it. Weighing in at 3 lbs 9 oz, it is well balanced and quite comfortable to hold in various positions. I have not enjoyed using a pure slate, including the TC1100, as much as I've enjoyed the F5. I can't over emphasize enough the value the handle and the flush 10.4" screen brings. In addition, the 32 GB SSD helps a lot with battery life, as I'm experiencing about 5 hours of battery life running Windows XP. As I noted in an earlier post, one of my customers, a cable manufacturer, already has their eye on one to use in shipping, receiving, and inventory management. The pen, SSD drive, integrated camera, integrated RFID, and handle were the features that won them over.

As I point out in this video review, though, there are several important weaknesses: no integrated USB ports, no support for touch, and a Core Solo processor. It is worth noting that many of the reasons field force workers would need USB ports are covered by the F5 integrating RFID, a barcode scanner, and Bluetooth for GPS connectivity. In addition, USB is available through the docking station and an optional vehicle dock. The lack of integrated USB ports, though, has bit me several times just this past week when trying to exchange data with customers or with other computers. Motion could get away with no USB with the healthcare focused C5, but I expect the lack of USB to be major pain point for potential F5 field force customers.

As I noted above, the 10.4" flush screen is a wonderful sweet spot for note-taking. Unfortunately, the $2699 starting price will put this slate Tablet PC out of reach for most consumers. I asked Motion about the potential for more consumer friendly Tablet PCs like the much requested ( and anticipated ) LS800 / LS900 variant. They told me they have no plans for an "LS900" or smaller form factor Tablet PC, but are always looking solutions that balance features, performance, and cost.

 


Monday, March 03, 2008 1:28:38 AM (Mountain Standard Time, UTC-07:00)
That's really sad they've abandoned the consumer market and won't even consider an upgrade to their popular LS800.
Monday, March 03, 2008 3:57:05 AM (Mountain Standard Time, UTC-07:00)
Agreed, all the agonizing guessing games that went on last week for this. Anonymous did give enough clues for the name (F5), rugged nature, and 3lb 9oz weight!

No thank you. This has officially narrowed my field down to the P1620 and the mythical beast that is the LG P100. Has anyone ever found a way to get one shipped to the US?

Kevin
Monday, March 03, 2008 7:37:39 AM (Mountain Standard Time, UTC-07:00)
It sounds like it is hard to get the pen out. The pen on the M1300 was simple and it was easy to get out and there were no moving parts to break. For the LS800 the pen became fancier but I had to get the pen bay repaired after it broke. I'd have gone back to the M1300 style instead of having a pen that is hard to get out without pulling it by the tether.

Does the pen tether get in the way of the camera? Is this the new version of the lens cap on the lens?
Monday, March 03, 2008 8:29:44 AM (Mountain Standard Time, UTC-07:00)
The F5 is a C5 clone for mobile field workers. No multi-touch, though it has WWAN (yawn). For my use case, fergetaboutit. On the bright side, Anonymous can stop torturing us!

Kevin, I'm with you on the P1620 vs. P100. I've blogged on the P100 (http://blogs.genghiskhent.com/?p=19). There's a link there to a thread where some Aussies are trying to get the P100, without much success so far.

Monday, March 03, 2008 9:49:44 AM (Mountain Standard Time, UTC-07:00)
I'm not sure if this is the new camera lens or not.

The tether string can get in the way of picture taking. I have the tether on there mostly to help in removing the pen. Otherwise, the pen is difficult to remove.
Rob
Monday, March 03, 2008 11:06:03 AM (Mountain Standard Time, UTC-07:00)
Ironically, for the past week, I've been enjoying using my new/old school HP DK503A ruggedized case for my TC1100. It's just $75 brand new boxed on eBay right now.

I've been very surprised and pleased how well the TC1100 functions within, while fully sealed against grease, dust and light water exposure. All ports are available via rubber gasket seals and LCD fully protected behind glare-reduction and stylus feel maintained textured hard covering. While adding bulk and 1.5lb weight, the rubber covered case handles well in such real adverse conditions. The DK503A used the same 26 drops onto plywood/concrete stress test as F5, although not running.

As a slate, the ruggedized combination functions very well, even for hours sessions. The case sealed raises temps 10 degrees (130's to 140's) but externally feels cool due to suspension design.

The TC1100 at $300-500 used, new HP batteries at $50 and the 503 case slashed deal offers a really viable alternative to the F5 at a fraction as low-end but still truly ruggedized 10.5" slate. The low risk/loss ratio, my 1Gz 1100 runs Vista well and handles any USB devices hooked up makes singularly unique package still relevant. Not as sleek or feature rich, but fills huge category price gap range.

The case slips open in seconds and the 1100 snaps onto desktop dock, selling now under $100 in continuous stream on eBay. The top ten ranked best ever tablet now has secondary market re purpose unmatched with accessories cheap and easily found, instead of rare and over-priced.
My IT grade dual charger cost $15 sealed new and two sealed new HP batteries found for $30 each. Those three retailed over $600 new. An ideal complete package for small-business tight budgets.

Slates in harsh field use need good software not horsepower armed with surplus of batteries exceeding expectations. When commodity priced, tools fit into workflow without lingering fears ever-present for damage handling the really expensive inside busy job sites. A red-hot metal shard falling onto either would melt hole right through. Among heavy machine environments, such risks soar. Few $4,000 slates will be left outside cases laying around, even ruggedized. Industrial settings are far more harsh than medical clinical situations, where conditions vary little. The market for the F5 seems the same slate users, supervisory or estimators or white collar perimeters on-site. The water-proof, drop-tolerance makes those users easy sales, but expanding within next frontier: actual workers in harsh settings and who need stylus input won't.

Touch input priced far, far cheaper, seen as commodity tool maybe. The new design looks like an appliance already at best and scarily child's toy wholly out of place at jobsites. One style right for nurses doesn't also fit for hardhats and filthy hands. Toughbooks look the part. The ribbing also helps holding smooth slab lacks. No one mistakes they're costly at glance, looking $300 when $3,000 impresses few of this crowd. The inability to display blueprints handed to on USB stick smacks of Steve Jobs arrogance to abuse customers. Unbelievable. Imagine how Fisher-Price your tablet will project explaining the flaw. Repeatedly.

It's one thing to bring in a ruggedized tablet for short-term, specialty tasks one owner responsible for and quite another thing adding one into workplace as new tool expected to survive daily assaults indefinitely. Losing individual control to group use of any slate better have bullet-proof design throughout. Swelling rubber fittings can't slip by.
bmhome1
Monday, March 03, 2008 11:28:36 AM (Mountain Standard Time, UTC-07:00)
Forgot to mention that links to the TC1100 accessories sited can be found at 1100 accessories thread in HP forum at tabletpcbuzz.com for anyone interested. I haven't posted here since 1100's are being sold while the secondary market buyers go there.
bmhome1
Tuesday, March 04, 2008 4:32:05 PM (Mountain Standard Time, UTC-07:00)

I agree wholeheartedly about the TC1100 still being packed with value. I recently sold all my accessories to another TC1100 user, and gave the slate and the rest to my father for Xmas. Damn was he happy ;) But I will admit to being a bit jealous, giving away such a slick machine :) It served me well for years.

That LG P100, for those that are having trouble finding it, is already for sale and in-stock here in Canada...

http://www.cdw.ca/shop/products/default.aspx?EDC=1409797
Frobozz
Tuesday, April 01, 2008 8:00:05 PM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
I thought of getting LG P100 myself but the fact that it uses passive digitizer turned me off. I still prefer active digitizer.
Cookie Monster
Comments are closed.


       





Copyright 2008 GottaBeMobile.com
 
     
 
     
 
     
 
     
  The vision of GottaBeMobile.com is to become the definitive source for mobile computing news, reviews, and commentary, as well as the home for the mobile community to discover and discuss these issues. When you think mobile, think GottaBeMobile.com.

The mobile computing space is one of the fastest growing and fastest changing spaces, and indeed industries worldwide. Within that constantly evolving and face paced world, GBM covers a range of spaces and technologies including Tablet PCs, UMPCs, MIDs, Ultra-portable computers, operating systems, software, natural human interfaces, accessories, mobile connectivity solutions, and other solutions that appeal to the mobile user.
     
Featured Stories
     
 
Search News

     
Latest GBM Shortcut Video Reviews and InkShows

 
News Categories
     
News Archive