Tablet PC and Ultra-Mobile PC News, Forums, and Video Reviews  
       
 
 
 

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

« Via Shipping Isaiah Samples to OEMsMain  | GBM InkShow: The New EverNote is a Game Changer »

What You Aren't Hearing: The Industry's Backward Step

- Rob Bushway

Keisha Barwise, also known as DrTigerLilly in our GBM forums, recently brought an issue to our attention regarding Stereo Mix being disabled by several OEMs. She has authored the following guest article for us on the issue.

- Keisha Barwise

If you just purchased a new laptop or desktop and you're used to being able to do things on your pc like record internet audio streams or broadcast audio over the internet, you might be discovering that this is no longer natively supported. As some users have discovered, the feature referred to as Stereo Mix (also known as Wave out or What you Hear across various sound card codecs), and the ability to record from it, has been silently disabled by several OEM's.  Stereo Mix also enables users to listen to audio over a USB tuner, recording audio from dvr software, online karaoke and do sound and music production.

There is speculation as to whether this is a response to pressure from the RIAA, in an effort to restrict piracy efforts. To date there has been no official word from any of the involved OEM's as to why the feature has been removed. Notebook & Desktop users alike, who find themselves with crippled machines, are being forced to use secondary sound cards or software fixes, such as programs like Virtual Audio Cable or Total Recorder. Some users have resorted to trying to hack drivers, often unsuccessfully; as well as resorting to low tech fixes such as looping a cable between the microphone and speaker ports, which only provides a mono recording.

These fixes don't always provide satisfactory solutions. Notebook users on the Thinkpad forums have discovered that the PCMCIA controller in the x6x/t6x notebooks is incompatible with popular PCMCIA sound cards, such as Creative's SoundBlaster Audigy 2zs. Other users have reported that available USB solutions don't appear to work either. Fortunately, many users have found Express Card solutions, but many laptops and Tablet PCs are not equipped with Express Card slots, thus being left out in the cold.

Two of the sound cards involved include the Sigmatel 92xx series and SoundMax Integrated Digital HD Audio. Unfortunately, most users aren't aware their machines have been crippled, until they have need for the feature. In addition, most OEMs don't list this feature in their product specifications.

Currently, OEMs offering drivers that re-enable the feature include Dell (who released new drivers in response to user outcry on their forums), Asus (desktop machines), Toshiba and HP. Lenovo has recently committed to investigating the matter in regards to their notebooks. Take a look over at Lenovo forums and let your voice be heard.

The questions we need to be asking OEMs are: Why was the feature removed? Why weren't consumers informed? Will the feature be re-enabled?  If it's important to you, don't hesitate to let your OEM know.


Tuesday, March 25, 2008 9:02:30 AM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
This is a big problem for me as it's how I record Skype calls for my podcast. In fact I would never buy a Sony laptop for this reason. The HP 2710p does works fine
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 9:04:15 AM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
I noticed on my Toshiba R15 that this feature disappeared in the move to Windows Vista.
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 9:09:58 AM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
Aaron: It's enabled on my R25 still running XP. Perhaps this is simply another driver issue with Vista (wouldn't be the first).
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 9:37:39 AM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
It's enabled on XP-based M700 as well, so I'd definitely point fingers at Vista-based drivers for now.
GoodThings2Life
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 9:45:40 AM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
XP has issues as well, as i've personally experienced with the x61 Tablet. I agree that in some Vista drivers it has been left out entirely...like with Dell's Sigmatel 92xx drivers, but some machines, i've found, such as Toshiba's A215 & HP's TX1000(Realtek HD Audio), work in vista, but you have to right click to show hidden devices in the recording tab of sound properties from control panel.
DRTigerlilly
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 10:16:53 AM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
In fairness to OEMs, hardly anyone ever uses Stereo Mix. Few people use audio input on their PCs. Of those, most use microphone input. Of the remainder, an external unit is a better bet since integrated audio usually isn't that good. It might be an issue of not updating a rarely used driver, especially given its sporadic nature. Not saying that sliver of users doesn't deserve driver support, but they are easy to overlook.
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 11:23:37 AM (Mountain Daylight Time, UTC-06:00)
yet another reason to give proprietary os's the middle finger...
turn_self_off
Comments are closed.


       





Copyright 2008 GottaBeMobile.com
 
     
 
     
 
     
 
     
  The vision of GottaBeMobile.com is to become the definitive source for mobile computing news, reviews, and commentary, as well as the home for the mobile community to discover and discuss these issues. When you think mobile, think GottaBeMobile.com.

The mobile computing space is one of the fastest growing and fastest changing spaces, and indeed industries worldwide. Within that constantly evolving and face paced world, GBM covers a range of spaces and technologies including Tablet PCs, UMPCs, MIDs, Ultra-portable computers, operating systems, software, natural human interfaces, accessories, mobile connectivity solutions, and other solutions that appeal to the mobile user.
     
Featured Stories
     
 
Search News

     
Latest GBM Shortcut Video Reviews and InkShows

 
News Categories
     
News Archive