MacBook Pro with Retina Display Review: First Impressions

The new MacBook Pro with Retina Display is more tempting in the flesh and many MacBook buyers will up sell themselves to the pricey machine once they put their hands on it. There’s no doubt that the new MacBook Pro with Retina Display sets a new standard, but there are some drawbacks that make the $800 premium over The standard MacBook Pro tougher to swallow.

I ordered a new custom MacBook Pro with Retina Display, but it won’t ship for another two to three weeks. In the meantime, I visited the San Francisco Apple Store where I’m hoping to purchase a retail configuration for review purposes. Apple is selling two models at retail for $2,199 and $2,799.  The cheaper model comes with a 2.3GHz processor and a 256GB SSD. The pricier model comes with a 2.6GHz processor and 512GB SSD. Both ship with with 8GB of memory. The optional 16GB of memory, 768GB SSD and 2.7GHz processor are only available online and can push the cost up to almost $4,000.

Apple’s MacBook Pro with Retina Display price points are huge deterrents for many potential buyers. Previous generation MacBook Pros debuted in similar price ranges, but that was long before the advent of the $999 MacBook Air and $1,199 13″ MacBook Pro. While some people will certainly be able to justify the $400 or so price premium over the thicker 15″ MacBook Pro, others won’t find enough reason to spend this kind of money on a laptop. Some people, such as those that need more than 256GB of storage in their primary machine,  will be better off buying a standard 15″ MacBook Pro as a desktop replacement and a MacBook Air as their portable machine for about the same cost as a MacBook Pro with Retina Display.

There are two big draws to the latest MacBook Pro. It’s much thinner and lighter than the previous model and of course the Retina Display. Spending 30 minutes or so with the MacBook Pro with Retina Display isn’t nearly enough to examine every aspect of the device. I’ll be sharing more thoughts as soon I find one available for purchase at an Apple Store. One thing is clear: the MacBook Pro with Retina Display is a winner. Apple’s managed to trim down the MacBook Pro and provided customers with enough new features to make up for any compromises.

Weighing in at 4.46 pounds, it is noticeably lighter than the standard MacBook Pro, which weighs more than a pound more. Though it’s just a hair lighter than the 13″ MacBook Pro, it feels significantly lighter since the new model is thinner and less dense.

20120613-084154.jpg

Here you can see how thick the new MacBook Pro is compared to the iPhone 4S. It clearly isn’t in the same neighborhood as the MacBook Air, but it is certainly thin enough to make this Apple’s first truly portable 15″ notebook .

Advertisement

The thinness does come at a cost however. The keys don’t have as much stroke, which means the typing experience isn’t as comfortable as with the old MacBook Pro. Typing on this keyboard feels just like typing on the 13″ MacBook Air. This won’t be a problem for some people, but it will be a serious problem for those accustomed to keyboards with more spring in them.

Apple states that the MacBook Pro Retina Display has less glare than the older MacBook Pro displays. That statement may be true, but the new display is more reflective than the MacBook Air’s display. You can see your reflection in the Retina Display, which is not desirable, especially for graphics professionals. Unfortunately, Apple isn’t offering a a Retina version of the optional matte/anti-glare display  offereed on the standard MacBook Pro. Note the white circles in the above, including the one by the model’s left eye. Those are ceiling lights and are just the sort of thing that make it difficult to edit photos and video.

The Retina Display is very nice and crisp thanks to its 2880 x 1800 resolution, but users will have to wait until the next version of OS X is released and applications are updated to accommodate the high pixel density. Some application icons and text are jagged, which can be distracting. It’s not the end of the world, but it isn’t something you wan to see on a $2,199 to $3,900 laptop.

MacBook Pro Retina Ports

The MacBook Pro with Retina Display is the first MacBook to come with an HDMI port. That’s a feature that’s been available on Windows notebooks for ages. Professionals will continue to connect to Apple Cinema Displays and ThunderBolt Displays with the Thunderbolt port, but the HDMI port will be very useful in a number of settings. More and more hotel rooms have HDTVs that can be used as external displays, but MacBook users are generally out of luck unless they happen to have a Mini Display Port to HDMI adapter.

Another  nice improvement is that the SD card slot is now on the right side of the MacBook Pro and away from the USB port. This means there’s less chance of USB peripherals getting in the way as is sometimes the case with the old MacBook Pro design.

The new MagSafe 2 adapter plugs into the left side of the MacBook Pro. This adapter is shorter and wider than its predecessor to accomodate the thinner MacBook design. There are now two Thunderbolt ports instead of just one, which will be of more benefit once Thunderbolt peripherals become more popular. For the first time, Apple’s removed the Kensington lock slot from the MacBook Pro, which means it cannot be secured with a security cable. That’s a big negative for some organizations.

 

MacBook Pro Retina Performance

The MacBook Air is still the king of thin and light, but it’s not powerful enough to edit video. Unlike the energy efficient MacBook Air components, the MacBook Pro with Retina Display uses the same components found in the thicker MacBook Pro. That means it’s speedy enough for creative video editing. Apple was displaying a sample Final Cut project that runs just shy of four minutes. I exported the project and it took a little over three minutes to complete the task. Your video editing mileage will vary depending on source content and how many effects are applied, but it blows away the MacBook Air.

One thing I really like about the new MacBook Pro with Retina Display seems to run cooler than previous models.  The old MacBook Pro gets hot enough to make it uncomfortable to use on your lap. The new MacBook Pro was warm to the touch after exporting the Final Cut project, but it was much cooler than I expected. It isn’t as cool as the MacBook Air 11″ or 13″, but that’s expected considering it has a full-speed processor and dedicated GPU.

The new MacBook Pro with Retina Display doesn’t have an optical drive, which shouldn’t be a problem most of the time. However, there are times where an optical drive is necessary and I recommend keeping an external optical drive handy just in case.  The trade-off of thinness and portability is worth this relatively minor inconvenience.

Here is Apple’s MacBook Pro with Retina Display video overview. Yes, it’s pretty much an extended commercial, but it is worth watching.

 

  

Comments

  1. Zachary Klein says

    “The Retina Display is very nice and crisp thanks to its 2880 x 1800 resolution, but users will have to wait until the next version of OS X is released and applications are updated to accommodate the high pixel density. Some application icons and text are jagged, which cn be distracting. It’s not the end of the world, but it isn’t something you wan to see on a $2,199 to $3,900 laptop.”

    No offense, but this is almost funny – we’re talking about a display with a DPI higher than any notebook on the market, an absolute technological breakthrough and potentially setting a new standard for displays, and we’re supposed to count the fact that third part apps will display text “jagged” (meaning, *exactly the same as the laptops we’re already using*) as a negative? It’s only “distracting” because Apple’s showing you how good it *can* and *should* be. Would we be better off if Apple made their native text rendering “jagged” so we couldn’t tell the difference?

    I do understand the contrast might be jarring, but from the tone of this review one would think that the retina display is a wash – nice colors and crisp detail, but some apps aren’t as good as others, so whatever.

    And before someone accuses me of being a fanboy, I have *no* intention of buying the new MBP. I’m excited that laptop display technology is finally getting attention again, and I hope this spreads to other manufacturers and other models soon. And I think any company that can create something this amazing deserves full credit. Even if they are Apple.

  2. Xavier Lanier says

    Zachary,I think my assessment is fair. The higher pixel count is impressive and it is a big step forward, but some people will want to wait until applications are updated. Apple’s own apps like Final Cut aren’t quite ready for the new display. Apple’s geting plenty of credit here.

  3. John says

    Xavier, there is not an $800 premium over the MacBook Pro. It’s $400. The 15″ Pro, not the 13″, compares to the 15″ Retina Display Pro. And it starts at $1799 while the Retina Display starts at $2199.

  4. bousozoku says

    It’s odd to me that Apple has been preparing for this kind of display technology since 10.4.x and they still don’t have a seamless way to do it.

    It seems every time they make a change, we have to wait for applications to be updated, and sometime, we have to pay for those updates. It’s almost as if they have no clue how to handle what they’ve proposed and they’re forcing it on everyone else to make up for their lack of ideas.

    • John says

      Apple made it as easy as they could. All developers have to do is scale their apps 2X. There’s a reason Apple doubled the amount of pixels as opposed to scaling them by 1.5. Also, Apple has been suggesting the doubling in scaling for many months. That’s how rumor sites were tipped off to the Retina display coming.

  5. LoriNYC says

    “Apple’s removed the Kensington lock slot from the MacBook Pro, which means it cannot be secured with a security cable. That’s a big negative for some organizations”… not necessarily, I have a MacBook Air, it has no lock slot as well and I was googling around and ran into this review http://youtu.be/SvK9wd1dIqY for Maclocks Macbook Air Lock and Security Case Bundle, the case is on the MBA all the time, I use the cable lock when I sit in the library or Starbucks, really works great for me :)

    Try to look here: http://www.maclocks.com/index.php/mac-locks.html

    Not sure they already have a lock for the new MBP but I guess it’s just a matter of weeks

  6. Travis Price says

    I own a 15 inch Macbook Pro with Retina display and I will say that I have been disappointed with how hot it gets. I had a two year old 17 inch Macbook pro that you literally could not use on your lap because it got so hot. I thought with the flash memory and lack of optical drive that temperature would not be an issue. The battery seems to be great, the speed is awesome, it’s a great machine, but all of that seems less important when you find yourself moving to the table because your “laptop” is not functional on your lap. Call it lazy or lame of me to want to sit on my couch and work, but Apple needs to not compromise cooling the device in their efforts to keep it slim.

  7. Scott says

    I am a hardcore Windows guy and I just bought the 15 MacBook Pro with Retina display. Mainly because if you want to do any native iOS dev you need one. Plus, the cost (around $2500) was close to the cost of the fully loaded Lenovo that I had spec’d out. I agree that it does get hot, but not nearly as hot as some of the PCs that I’ve used over the last few years. The battery has been insanely good, especially for a high end machine. I did go with the 256GB SSD because the cost of the larger hard drive AND 16GB memory was just too much cash. It added like $900. I will say the Retina display is incredible. That is the one thing that I think sets this apart from any other machine I have used. It’s beautiful. Its actually disappointing when you come across something that doesn’t look good at this high of resolution. (like this page). Overall, I would recommend it.

  8. says says

    can we use the macbook pro without Retina version and upgrade it to 16GB , will it still work? some one told me they bought the new Macbook pro in USA and upgrade the ram to 16GB , it works fine. just want to confirm if this will void the warranty, as it cannot be configured on a CTO model too.

Leave a Reply