Galaxy S Pen and Holder Kit Mini-Review

Samsung’s Galaxy Note comes with a skinny digitizer pen called the S Pen that users can stow away inside the phone when they’re not using it. I like the extra functionality this enables — see my review of the GNote for all the details — but people with big hands often find small styli like this uncomfortable to use.

If you’re more comfortable using a regular-sized pen, Samsung has an accessory that should please you. The Galaxy S Pen and Holder Kit has both an extra S Pen and a Holder that makes it the size of a normal pen. You get the side-button functionality and everything, just in a larger form factor.

How much is this comfort worth? Read this mini review to find out.

Galaxy S Pen and Holder Kit

The S Pen holder could be mistaken for a typical pen the way it’s designed. Smooth, glossy black plastic dominates except near the tip where there’s a rubberized coating for greater comfort. This is also where you’ll find the S Pen’s side button, which sits more naturally under the fingers than on the smaller version.

Twisting the rubberized bit opens up the holder and the small S Pen itself fits inside. You can use either the replacement S Pen that comes with the holder or the one that comes with the Galaxy Note or other replacement S Pens you may have to buy in the future. Any of them will work.

Galaxy S Pen Holder Open

Advertisement

Slide the smaller pen in and twist it back together and you’re set. No batteries necessary. With the S Pen inside, the whole thing is a little heavier than a typical pen, but not so much that this is a problem.

Even though I have no issues using the small S Pen, I found using it with the holder much more comfortable overall. It feels natural in my hand and the balance is good. And because the holder is longer than the S Pen it’s easier to write on the screen without touching it with your palm. I also noticed a little more accuracy when drawing shapes in the Crayon Physics game.

Galaxy S Pen Holder

Because the side button sits under where my fingers naturally go I was more inclined to use it for the Home, Menu and Back gestures, thus eliminating the need to use my finger on the buttons.

The main drawback to the S Pen Holder is that there’s no clever way to attach it to the Galaxy Note. If you value having the port right therefor storage  it may put you off using the larger pen.

Another drawback is price; $60 is quite a bit of cash. $40 of that is the S Pen itself (you can buy an extra here without the holder). Unfortunately, Samsung doesn’t sell the holder on its own.

If $60 just seems like too much there are alternatives. I have a digitizer pen from an older ThinkPad tablet PC lying around and decided to try it on the Galaxy Note — it worked, side button and all. You can buy digitizer pen replacements for as little as $33. Non-ThinkPad digitizer pens may work as well. See update below.

Of course any capacitive stylus will also work on the display, but you won’t get the extra functions that come from the digitized pen (screenshots, gestures) or the fine point accuracy.

Is the S Pen and Holder Kit worth it? If the size of the S Pen is really a problem for you then the larger holder will make your experience more comfortable. But this accessory isn’t the only fix for that problem. That it comes with an extra S Pen is a bonus, but I do wish Samsung sold the holder alone. The high price hinders an otherwise recommendable accessory.

Update: Commenter Tim Walker points out that AT&T is selling the same kit for just $29.99. I was able to find a direct link so you don’t have to add the GNote first. For $30 I definitely recommend this accessory. Thanks, Tim!

Advertisement

Comments

  1. Tim Walker says

    at and t wireless has the kit for $29.  I just bought it.  Here’s how: go to there site, add the galaxy note to your cart, it will then show you a list of available accessories below.  Choose the s pen kit, then go to your cart.  Remove the phone, and order the s spen kit.  I have a shipping confirmation, so this will work.

  2. Dorian says

    hi I would like to know if the s-pen with holder kit can be used on the iPad? can you test it out and see if it works?

  3. Andy E says

    Hi I would also like to know if the s pen works on ipad? cant stand the standard stylus pens

  4. KaiAdin says

    Any Wacom “Penabled” Digitiser stylus should work with the Galaxy note!

    ThinkPad Tablets, some HP Tablet-pc tablets, Motion Computing, and most other tablet-pc brands use Wacom penabled! Wacom themselves used to sell generic unbranded replacement styluses themselves and they can be found on ebay and the like.

    One thing to look out for though is that you cant use the stlylses from any of Wacoms Graphics tablet range (Bamboo,Graphire,Intuos,Cintiq) as they use a different pen technology.

Leave a Reply