Why I’m Not Buying the iPad mini or iPad 4th Gen

Apple introduced two new iPads this week – the iPad mini and iPad 4th generation. However, I don’t plan to buy either of them. The iPad mini costs too much for using last year’s technology, and the new 4th gen iPad doesn’t add enough to make upgrading worth the expense and hassle.

The iPad 4th generation gains more than a Lightning adapter, Apple also adds a new processor with better graphics power, a FaceTime HD camera and now support Sprint as a wireless option. The iPad 4th gen now supports faster Wi-Fi for better streaming and downloading on advanced WiFi networks.

I’d love a faster iPad, but not enough to go through the hassle of selling my current iPad. I don’t like the idea of getting in a virtual line on the web to pre-order the 32GB LTE iPad 4th generation for $729. Even after selling my current iPad, the cost to upgrade is $350.

That’s why I won’t upgrade to the 4th gen iPad.

Apple needed to do three things to push me to buy the iPad mini.

  • Make it possible to easily swap iPad SIM cards so I don’t need another data plan
  • Offer iPhone 5 caliber hardware
  • Price the iPad mini below $300

iPad Mini

The iPad mini costs too much for yesterday’s technology

Advertisement

The early 2012 iPad uses a micro-SIM card while the iPad mini requires a nano-SIM like the one in the iPhone 5. I can use an adapter like this one from Amazon so that’s not a big issue. If that was the only problem, I’d probably buy one.

Apple bumped up the specs on the larger iPad, but didn’t put the same advanced hardware in the iPad mini. I’m most disappointed that they left out the high res Retina Display available on the iPhone 5 and larger iPad.

I’m not going to pay a premium price for yesterday’s hardware. I’m sure it will run and sell well in spite of this, but I don’t think it’s worth adding a second iPad to my gadget bag. I’m definitely not replacing my current iPad for the iPad mini, with nearly equal specs.

The 16GB Nexus 7 costs $249. Everyone who got to hold the iPad mini in the post announcement hands-on agrees that the iPad mini hardware feels like excellent workmanship. That’s great, but my Nexus 7 holds up well at a more affordable price. I always keep my tablets in a case so I don’t notice the rubber and plastic on the Nexus 7 or the aluminum of the iPad. After multiple drops the Nexus 7 holds up well.

The Wifi only 16GB iPad Mini is too limiting for my use. iPad apps take up a lot of space, and I need Internet access anywhere i travel. Instead of paying $329 for the lowest cost iPad mini, I would need to buy the iPad Mini 32GB with LTE for $559.

At that price the iPad mini is a luxury I’m not willing to buy.

Comments

  1. Rod says

    Thank you!!! Couldn’t have said it better myself… Just a little pissed that my 6month old iPad 3 just became obsolete… These guys have it nailed on keeping the sheep upgrading…

  2. Rod says

    And on another note…. iPad 1 users should really be fuming…. No iOS updates beyond 5.1…. C’mon, REALLY? I’m already seeing apps that require iOS 6. Damn thing is only 2 years old. Used to be a windows type guy for the freedom (hated apple), but grew to love apple because their stuff always works with little hassle (tired of playing computer geek- now i just want to turn a computer on, get the job done and turn the thing off without having to do all the maintenance). I used to get a kick out of playing computer-boy, but at this point in my life I have more important stuff to do, so I just treat it as an appliance for simple tasks (remember web tv?). My last PC purchase eons ago was a pentium 4 w/ XP that still runs my entertainment center till this day- just upgraded to the newest Internet Explorer and runs great… Apple makes great stuff, but they are getting greedy—gonna bite them in the ass eventually…

  3. Bill Moore says

    If I had an iPad 3, I would probably think similarly, Kevin. As it stands, I’m awfully tempted to buy a refurbished 3rd gen. iPad 32GB wifi model for $469 from the Apple Store. Is the 4th gen. iPad’s bump in speed very noticeable in applications outside of certain intensive games? Frankly, I doubt it, but I’ve been wrong before.

    And then again, the rumored Nexus 10 is awfully tempting. If it is as good as the Nexus 7 has been, it may be the way to go. I’m not invested in one eco-system or the other, having only a very few paid apps on my iPhone 4S.

    Any thoughts or things to consider would be appreciated.

  4. use_common_sense says

    The Kindle Fire, Nexus 7 are better options (money wise) than the iPad mini and the Surface with Office RT is definitely a very good alternative (better one if you need office to get stuff done) to any iPad!

    I’m definitely hoping customers start appreciating other alternatives besides the iPad! :)

Leave a Reply