iPhone 4 Bumper is no match for my Death Grip

So I was out at a local festival today and opted to bum around the Apple Store while my wife went to Pottery Barn (again). Seeing a whole column of Bumpers on the shelf, I took advantage of the opportunity and bought one. While it fulfills the purpose of the purchase, I was surprised to discover its rubber and plastic shell is no match for my signal-killing Death Grip.

As I stated previously, while I appreciate the strength of the iPhone 4’s steel frame, I do find it uncomfortable in hand. Interestingly, the genius who processed my purchase brought up the comfort problem without prompting. In addition, the lustrous glass panels make it impossible to rest my iPhone on a curved surface, such as the arm of my sofa or the leg of me. The Bumper addresses both of these issues very well. The feel is much closer to that of my familiar and comfortable 3G and my one-thumb typing style is back up to speed.

I had initially planned on holding out for Apple to give away Bumpers to address the antenna Death Grip problem. But since Apple was kind enough to give me 40 SIM cards, which people actually pay money to buy on eBay, I figured I’ve already been compensated. That seems to have been the smarter decision since the Bumper has fallen to the might of my Death Grip.

While a case or covering has proven effective for others, including Warner, I can still drive down the bars through the Bumper using the left-handed so-called Death Grip. The grip is less effective, dropping two bars from three but not killing the signal unless it’s already at one bar (my results at this level are inconclusive), but it still works as quickly as without the Bumper. This pokes a giant hole in my prior belief that contact with the frame was a necessary element. I must conclude that, at least in my case, the problem does stem from my hand blocking the antenna.

I no longer believe the external nature of the antenna is a direct cause here but rather a contributing factor. Being on the outside, the antenna is easier to envelop with one’s hand. The Bumper and other cases add distance from the hand, very little but apparently enough to keep it from entirely blocking the signal. I’m sure there are others affected by this problem differently. For example, simply bridging the two antennas is not enough to affect my signal like it does for others.

Regardless, the Death Grip problem has been primarily an intellectual exercise for me. It only affects my iPhone when held in a precise manner that I would not normally use. That particular grip is not natural for me and only seems effective in my left hand, while I’m a righty who practices and preaches one-handed operation of touchscreen handhelds. My only real problem were the hard edges and slick back panel, which the Bumper has solved. Of course, there’s always a trade-off: the opening for the dock connector is too narrow for my old iPod cables. Seems fitted specifically for the iPhone cable with the smaller dock connection. It’s always something…

13 Comments

  1. GoodThings2Life

    07/10/2010 at 8:35 pm

    You’re not alone in this finding, as numerous YouTube videos and reports are suggesting the same thing… bumper or not, they still lose signal.

    Reply

  2. Ben

    07/10/2010 at 9:43 pm

    I bought an iFrogz from Best Buy and love it. Great feel/texture…doesn’t slip on surfaces and I have not had any issues with signal loss. Just for the record, I’m not paid by nor do I work for iFrogz. Just a normal guy.

    Ben

    Reply

  3. RR

    07/11/2010 at 1:07 am

    Don’t look at “signal bars”, they don’t give you precise information, look at the RSSI in dBm. Holding any phone normally will result in a 5dB loss on average. Touching both the iPhone4 external antennas at the same time results in a 20dB loss. That’s why you still see some loss with the bumper, but more loss without it.

    Reply

  4. tivoboy

    07/11/2010 at 6:35 am

    no death grip necessary, all one has to DO is TOUCH the phone.

    checkout the bullet points in this video

    Reply

    • Sumocat

      07/11/2010 at 6:49 am

      I agree there is a specific problem causing a simple touch to interfere with some iPhone 4s, but it’s not affecting mine. I can’t kill the signal just by bridging the antennas, nor is the Bumper stopping the problem entirely.

      Reply

  5. tivoboy

    07/11/2010 at 4:34 pm

    have you tried the method in this video, on the upload side. It also kills things like SMS transmission for me

    Reply

    • Sumocat

      07/11/2010 at 5:51 pm

      I don’t know how or why, but I just tried it and touching that spot is now proving enough to block the connection on Speedtest and bring down the bars. That wasn’t happening in my initial tests or in subsequent observations. I even tried it on my tests on Tuesday with no effect, though the degradation could have been within the usual range of variance. Think I’ll just stick to being baffled by the problem.

      Reply

      • Sumocat

        07/12/2010 at 8:47 am

        Ran a series of tests at my office. Death Grip without the Bumper had a clear effect, but touching the Death Spot proved ineffective. Download speeds were actually faster than one of my control tests (no touching). Upload speeds were within my normal range and there was no deceleration.

        Reply

        • tivoboy

          07/12/2010 at 9:10 am

          So, if you have a STRONG FIVE bar signal, you won’t get ANY degradation – regardless.

          If one has 2-4 bars, I can’t degrade it all the time.

          Reply

  6. Pat

    07/12/2010 at 2:28 am

    Let’s try to wait for the update and see if it will really solve the antenna problem.

    We have a Gumdrop Skin on our iPhone 4, btw.

    Reply

  7. tivoboy

    07/12/2010 at 9:08 am

  8. Dennisvjames

    07/13/2010 at 6:31 am

    Jobs says it’s your fault. :-) and you should hold the phone differently. Sounds like the only different way to hold one is using your pinky finger and thumb, or really getting clever and using your toes.

    Reply

    • acerbic

      07/13/2010 at 7:56 pm

      In a handstand with the toes of your right foot.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *