Smoked by Windows Phone Drama Arises
Over the weekend, there was a bit of drama that took place at a Microsoft Store in Santa Clara. Sahas Katta from Scatter Tech headed down with his Samsung Galaxy Nexus to give the “Take the $1,000 Windows Phone Challenge” a go. This is a new challenge that derived from the “Smoked by Windows Phone” challenge that popped up at CES 2012. The original challenge gave users a chance to win $100 cash if you could beat Ben Rudolph, a Microsoft employee in a simple challenge. The challenges range from taking and uploading a photo to Facebook to posting a status update to Facebook and Twitter. The promotion went over well and went viral and turned out becoming a full fledge ad campaign.
Microsoft recently bumped up the states and started offering a $1,000 custom PC if you win and a free Windows Phone if you lose. These challenges are taking place in Microsoft Stores around the US.
You could win a Hunger Games Special Edition PC, valued at over $1000. And even if you lose, you still win, because we’ll give you a free Windows Phone.*
Sahas Katta entered the Microsoft Store and on his account, won. Microsoft Store employees, including the manager, said he didn’t.
I excitedly thought I won out of pure luck. However, I was quickly told that I lost. I asked for a reason and was told Windows Phone won because “it displays the weather right there.” That was rather unclear. I showed her my device which also was showing off the same information with two side-by-side weather widgets on the center home screen. After pressing for a better reason, I was told that Windows Phone won “just because.”
After trying to push for a real answer since I clearly won the contest by their rules, another Microsoft Store employee (possibly a manger) came by after noticing me asking more questions. Thinking on his feet, he quickly gave a ridiculous out-of-thin-air reason that I need to display the weather of different cities in different states and that “my phone could not do that”.
1st off, this story also points out a bit of precooking, or cheating by Microsoft. The way Sahas should have won by having widgets showing the weather prior to arrival is the same way Microsoft planned to win that challenge… by having tiles prepinned prior to the challenge.
I’ve had a feeling something like this would show up soon or later. I had thought about taking my HTC Titan and putting it up against my Galaxy Nexus in a series of tests of my own but never got around to it.
One of the problems I have with the challenge is that they cater to Windows Phone’s strengths.
- Updating Facebook and Twitter at the same time is something that Microsoft takes pride in having built into the OS. The good news for some Android users is that this feature is built into Tweetcaster, the Twitter client I use.
- Taking a photo and uploading it to Facebook, again a strength Windows Phone has with easy sharing of photos to Facebook and Skydrive. The big advantage is being able to activate the camera without unlocking the phone too. How about a race uploading a 30 second video to some social media venue? That’s right, Windows Phone can’t do this.
- Find a restaurant and get directions. This could go either way seeing that Bing and Google Maps are fairly competent with this task. The advantage should still go to Windows Phone with the Local Scout app that was added with Windows Phone Tango.
- Texting is just a matter of how quick the user is and this test could go either way in my opinion. Advantage nobody.
Take the fact that the home team (Microsoft) chooses the task and the Microsoft contestant has most likely been trained to maneuver the tasks for the challenge, it’s really not a fair fight either way. In watching all the videos from CES and more recent events, Ben the PC Guy is getting the tasks done before the competitor even formulates the path to accomplish the task on their phone.
I will be honest, I do love seeing these videos and like to see Windows Phone do well, but I want to see it on a level playing field. The positive attention that Microsoft has gotten with these challenges seems to be well received online and absolutely helps Windows Phone’s awareness. Incidents like this are going to set it back some though.
Source: Skatter Tech (via)
03/25/2012 at 10:41 pm
Is anybody truly surprised at this? Microsoft has been desperate to promote this, and this is just a ploy to get your picture taken with that sign. Microsoft isn’t the most ethical company on the planet.
03/26/2012 at 4:39 pm
Isn’t that how marketing works? You play up your strengths and emphasize your competitions weaknesses. It is no different than the mac and pc adds.
I agree the store employees screwed it up though and should have paid up.
03/29/2012 at 8:24 pm
I went to the “Smoked by Windows Phone Challenge” in Houston Galleria, I was told to find directions to the closest 4* restaurant. Sales rep didn’t find directions he just found locations of closest restaurant, at the same time I found directions. When I showed it sales rep, he told me that I was trying to cheat and offered me redo, when I found closest restaurants faster then him he again told me again that I was cheating. I don’t understand how Microsoft wants to get back on the Market when they are clearly not follow rules. And how they want to compete with somebody who’s customer service trained way better then them.