Hands-on: Spotify is a Tour de Force for Mobile Music Lovers
With last week’s launch of the Spotify music subscription service in the US, American listeners now have the option of joining their European pals in an all-you-can-eat musical smorgasbord. After spending some time with a Premium subscription, we have to say that this is a buffet that many music lovers won’t want to miss.
Service and Availability
If you’ve heard about Spotify invites and kept away because you didn’t feel like tracking one down, have no fear – you can join immediately. Free memberships are not yet open in the US, and for those you will need an invite. However, those wanting to jump right in can become a member instantly by simply signing up for one of Spotify’s paid options.
Those paid options are:
- Unlimited – which, for $5/month gives you unlimited streaming and no ads
- Premium – which gives you all of that plus access to mobile apps and music storage for offline listening. Those with iOS and Android devices will then want the $10 Premium plan.
The Spotify Experience
Having played with Spotify on iOS for a while now, we are very pleased. The music selection is outstanding. Of course there are no Beatles tracks, but we all know Apple has the digital incarnation of the Fab Four locked up exclusively for now. Otherwise, most songs and albums we searched for – ranging from recent to decades-old, popular to somewhat obscure – were there. There were enough exceptions to remind us that they don’t quite have everything, but it’s close enough that few are likely to be even remotely disappointed.
Some songs will be unlocked to all but Premium users. These will be shaded out for Unlimited or Free members, but will be ready and waiting for those forking over $10 per month.
Searching for songs is quick and easy. Results pop up instantly, and – provided your connection is good – songs will generally start playing almost immediately after clicking on them.
Playlists are at the heart of your Spotify experience. If you want an album to be saved in your Spotify library, creating a playlist is the way to do it. If you want a single song to be saved on its own – again, it will be via playlist. Want to create a virtual “mix tape” of booty rap songs from the early 90’s? Yep – playlist. Playlists are a cinch to create. Individual songs or entire albums can be easily and quickly added to one.
Social is another core element of Spotify. When you find a song you like, you can share it via email, Facebook, or Twitter. You can even share entire playlists. When friends get your recommendation, they simply click a link and can then play it in their own Spotify player. They also have the option to add it to their own libraries. As with every other part of the iOS app, sharing is implemented in a remarkably simply and efficient manner, and can happen in a matter of a few seconds.
One big advantage Spotify has over other subscription services is the ability to sync local music files. This lets you fill in the few gaps that Spotify has with your own music. Two albums we came across, Play and 18 by Moby, weren’t available on Spotify.
But since we had the two albums on our PC, we only had to create a playlist on our PC that includes the local files, open the Spotify iPhone app while on the same network, marking that playlist as “available offline,” and it synced.
Now the two best albums from the techno-making vegan are in our Spotify library. Sure, it requires using some storage on your iPhone, but with all of the space you’re saving from the rest of the music that Spotify does have, that shouldn’t be an issue.
Spotify vs. the Competition
Of course unlimited music streaming memberships are really nothing new in the US. While it never really got a hip and fun aura attached to it (as Spotify currently has), Rhapsody has been offering essentially the same thing for years (though Spotify’s local file syncing is absent in Rhapsody). The more recent Rdio is also basically the same thing, with more of an emphasis on social networking (and also a less extensive catalog). Grooveshark is another competitor, who has the biggest “catalog” – but is operating on shaky legal ground (and is therefore only available on jailbroken iPhones).
Which of these services is for you? That will likely depend on your taste. We prefer Spotify due to its large (and legal) catalog, local syncing, and for its simple and attractive interface on mobile. But another huge perk is that Spotify offers sharing of tracks and playlists without jamming the social element down our throats.
For those who love finding a new social network and making friends – perhaps Rdio is better for you. Those of us who like a more subtle social element will prefer Spotify.
No matter which you choose, though – we think all-you-can-eat music subscriptions are the easiest and most enjoyable form of cloud music. Take this model vs. some of the other current and upcoming cloud music options:
- Internet radio services like Pandora and Last.fm are great for building “stations” around songs or artists, but if there is something specific you’re looking for, you’ll have to create a station and wait – hoping for it to come up. These are great when a genre is what you want – but not so great when specific songs or albums are what you want.
- Google Music and Amazon Cloud Player both require your uploading your entire music collection – and require individual purchases (or uploading from elsewhere) in order to get new music.
- The upcoming iTunes Match will scan your library and instantly add all tracks to the cloud, but it requires you to download it all to your iDevice (it doesn’t stream). It also, of course, requires purchases for new music.
- Subscription services like Spotify, on the other hand, give you the chance to have nearly all the music you’d ever want at your fingertips. You don’t have to download anything, but the option is there (especially nice for those on capped data plans).
When it comes down to it, $10 a month to listen to (almost) any music you want – including on your mobile device (online and off) – is going to be a solid trade-off for most people. It’s 24/7 instant gratification for the music lover in you. Sure, there will be the occasional frustration of looking up an album that isn’t there, or a track that is blacked out – but those are the exceptions rather than the rules. Local syncing can fill in those gaps, provided you have the songs’ files. Spotify can bring a world of music to any device you own without a single upload, download, or transfer.
07/19/2011 at 2:42 pm
I have to respectfully disagree somewhat. You glossed over MOG and Rdio – which are basically identical services to Spotify. Rdio has the smallest library and I have already dropped that service in favor of MOG with ~11 million or so songs at last report.
Spotify touts a larger library … and yet in every single instance I checked, where there was a discrepancy in availability MOG had more than Spotify (mostly Jazz and 20th century Classical). My gut tells me that the 15 million is not very ‘truthy’, since even some of the stuff I added to my playlists when trying the UK service earlier this year is unavailable.
Also, I was surprised at how many problems I have had with the iOS and Android apps for Spotify. For MOG sometimes song start-ups would be a bit slow as it buffered, but for Spotify I have had repeated crashes dealing with playlists (word of advice – don’t bother creating playlists on iOS, apparently it is a widespread crasher), songs that just sit forever and won’t play, differences in availability of songs on mobile versus PC, and so on. Still a bit half-baked, IMO.
Not that I don’t love Spotify – I signed up for Premium immediately – just that I am a bit underwhelmed based on prior experience and expectations.
07/19/2011 at 5:23 pm
Michael, I had much the same impression as you. Posted about it on my blog. (See my comment after yours for the link)
07/19/2011 at 5:25 pm
I had actually seen your post linked from another review (was it on DMN?) and thought it was a pretty solid overview of the services. Thanks for sharing here as well!
07/20/2011 at 4:08 am
I’ve used Pandora for some time on both iPhone and Android and so far, Spotify’s client has been a great deal more stable. I couldn’t leave the Pandora app paused as it would eventually (fairly quickly) crash. Spotify’s has been rock-solid. Also, the performance between the two is stark – Spotify is as solid as hitting <play" and Pandora sometimes gets lost in bufferland. I can't disagree about the jazz/classical libraries but if I were creating a music service, those genres wouldn't exactly be my top two concerns…no offense (esp. since I just set up a wonderful classical album on Spotify that emulates a Pandora "station" by including lots of artists). Cheers!
07/20/2011 at 4:09 am
That’s hilarious – apparently this site doesn’t strip out any characters that could be interpreted as HTML. Hmm, someone should run a web app security assessment against it before the bad guys do…
07/19/2011 at 5:22 pm
Here’s the post I made to my blog on music subscription services comparing my first impressions of Spotify premium to Rhapsody, Mog, and rdio:
07/20/2011 at 4:02 am
Sure, Grooveshark is not on iOS devices without Jailbreaking, but for those Android users, I’d say it’s pretty attractive. It’s an Adobe Air app, so it works the same on OS X and Windows, and I don’t have to put up with ads. I can upload my own music, create playlists, favorite and share, and it’s cheaper than Spotify.
07/20/2011 at 6:19 am
Buy spotify invitations here: https://cgi.ebay.com/Spotify-FREE-USA-INVITATION-INVITE-TOKEN-/250857998196?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item3a684d4774#ht_3830wt_1346 great price and great service!
07/20/2011 at 10:46 am
DO NOT … I REPEAT DO NOT *BUY* a Spotify Invite – there are tons to go around. Check this list I published (https://www.geardiary.com/2011/07/18/music-diary-deal-round-up-of-spotify-invite-links/) , or head to SlickDeals (https://slickdeals.net/forums/showthread.php?t=3118256), or even to Klout (https://klout.com/perk) … and you will get one.
Worst case contact me, I have a few left over. But PLEASE don’t buy one!
07/21/2011 at 12:26 am
Well maybe you had to wait, but it’s so much cheaper for you guys! We pay £9.99/$16 for what you pay $10 for :-(