Connect with us


Why Apple’s Competitors Can’t Compete With the iPad’s $500 Price Point



Now that the Motorola Xoom is announced and will soon hit the shelves at retail outlets we will see if people are willing to pay a price premium for an Android tablet. Our guess is they won’t. So why doesn’t Motorola undercut Apple, the current tablet sales trendsetter?

Most observers are saying that the $500 iPad has the perfect price point and if the upstart wants to win this fight or just compete they need to at least meet Apple’s price and probably beat it. A really good $399 Android Tablet would likely sell well. Case in point: the Samsung Galaxy Tab is selling well and right now buyers can snag one at T-Mobile with a two-year contract for $249.99 or $499.99 without the weight of the contract. Other carriers have decent prices too on Samsung’s Tab.

Screen shot 2011 02 22 at 8 16 00 AM

So why is the Xoom starting out at $799 without a contract and $600 for the Wi-Fi only version? They want you to believe it is because of its superior specs – it has the 4G LTE network capability, will run flash, and Android 3.0, an OS designed for tablets without the closed nature of the iOS app store. It also has more flash memory than the $500 iPad. But is all that worth $300 or $100 for the Wi-Fi only version? And by the way, the Xoom won’t have Flash capability out the door. Engadget reported that it won’t be till Spring before it gets it. We don’t think consumers will see the iPad next to the Xoom and say the latter is worth an extra $100-$300.

Motorola xoom

The answer, according Jason Hiner at Tech Republic, is that other vendors can’t compete with Apple on the price point because they can’t make a comparable profit on each unit.  Apple makes a $500 16GB iPad for about $230 according to iSuppli. That’s $270 to cover things like marketing and overhead. No one knows how much of that is pure profit but the bean counters at Apple.

When you add the fact that Apple sells their iPads directly to the customer via the online and offline Apple Store. Some are sold at third-party retailers like Best Buy and Target. But most go directly from Apple to a customer. Cutting out the middle man adds to Apple’s bottom line. No one else has that kind of leverage. For that reason, they are not able to price their tablets at the same price as Apple without cutting the profit margin too thin. They would likely determine it is not worth the effort to produce in the first place. The solution is to partner with the wireless carriers to make up the difference. They know that Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile and Sprint will subsidize the difference and sell the tablets at or below Apple’s $500 price. Could this be why we haven’t seen the Wi-Fi only Samsung Galaxy Tab?

What they miss is that most people don’t want to add another wireless bill or add to the one they already have. Why do they think people jailbreak iPhones to add wireless tethering for a one time fee of about $20 versus the monthly $20 fee Verizon and now AT&T are charging. Even that is more likely than a $30-$60 data plan for a 3G or 4G tablet. A lot of the 3G iPads sold were never even activated. Tablets are tools to be used at home or work where Wi-Fi is prevalent. When on the road there is often a Wi-Fi signal just a coffee shop away. The cell phone model will help sell a few over-priced Android tablets. But we don’t expect them to sell enough to make them anything but blips on the tablet sales graph while Apple chugs along with the iPad 2 about to be release and likely to sell tens of millions.



  1. Terry

    02/22/2011 at 2:46 pm

    A few points to consider:

    The Samsung Tab is 7″ and does not run Honeycomb but rather an older version of Android. Thus, it is not comparable to the iPad and it is a little expensive for what you get. The newer Tab 2 (Galaxy 10.1) will be a 10.1″ tablet running Android Honeycomb and will be more comparable to the iTab, or more probably the iTab 2. But the pricing is still unclear for this new Samsung offering, impressive though its specs sound.

    Apple is a premium brand; everyone knows that Apple computers and gadgets like the phones and pods and pads come with a premium price, but it is expected to be premium quality. Apple software is top quality, as is most of their hardware. Thus, when people spend $499 on a basic iPad (ranging up to $800 for 3G and more memory) they know they are getting a Cadillac and are prepared to spend for one.

    By contrast, there are $100 Android tablets now coming out of factories in China. They are cheaply thrown together, they won’t last very long, some of the displays are bad, and the software is still previous generation. But, like the IBM PC clones, they will end up sweeping the market.

    Few are going to pay $800 for an android tablet a year from now. The Xoom will have to come down in price because Motorola does not have the gold plated image that Apple has. Will MOT even be in business in a year or two? They just sold off half their company. Their phones have been uneven in quality. Yes, the Xoom is a great product–on paper–but it will need to sell for under $500 to capture significant market share.

  2. anonymous

    02/22/2011 at 3:11 pm

    When comparing prices of the android to the iPad, don’t forget to add in the iPad 3G charge ($130) when comparing to the android 3G/4G…When you say that android costs $100-300 it should be $100 – $170 more because the iPad comparible model is $629 and that is only 3G not 4G.

  3. John

    02/23/2011 at 5:20 am

    I don’t know… I am not a huge fan of Apple or anything they make anymore. Most of the iPhone’s and iPod’s I have bought ended up freezing and dying, or breaking. They just aren’t as high a quality as everyone makes them out to be. And the “Apple” experience is not all that amazing either, Android is just as good, if not better

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.