Amazon Music HD and Tidal HiFi are the go-to music streaming services for audiophiles and people that care about how their music sounds. Both services outclass Spotify, Apple Music, YouTube Music and other services in the quality department with higher bitrate options.
If you have a discerning ear and good equipment to listen on, you’re likely going to choose Amazon Music HD or Tidal for your streaming service.
Ultimately you will need to choose one, which is what we will help you do, but you can sign up for a free trial of both options so that you can make the ultimate call.
Each service offers a no risk-free trial, so you are able to compare the two with your own ears. Cancel within the trial period and you won’t pay anything.
Tidal HiFi vs Amazon Music HD
This guide is focusing on the higher quality, and more expensive, plans that Amazon and Tidal offer. There is Tidal HiFi, which compares to Amazon Music HD and Amazon Music Ultra HD.
The base plans offered by each of the services only offer up to 320kbps bitrate, but they are more affordable with prices as low as $1 for Amazon Music and as low as $5 a month for Tidal if you qualify for special pricing.
Amazon Music HD
|Audio Quality||1411 kbps for Tidal HiFi, 2,304-16,934 kbps (master/studio quality, up to 24 bit, 352.8 kHz) MQA tracks||
850 kbps for HD, 3730 max for Ultra HD
|Number of Songs||More than 60 Million HiFi, 200,000+ tracks in MQA||
More than 50 Million in HD, Millions in Ultra HD
|Mobile Apps||iPhone, iPad, Apple TV, Android||
iPhone, iPad, Apple TV, Android
|Smart Speakers||Alexa, Google Assistant and more.||
Alexa, Google Assistant for Play/Pause
|Desktop Apps||Windows and Mac||
Windows and Mac
|Exclusive Tickets & Music||Yes||No|
Tidal offers more music at higher quality, but Amazon Music HD is cheaper for most individuals. The Masters Quality Authenticated audio should offer the best sound quality on the included tracks, but Amazon Music Ultra HD offers a wider range of tracks at higher than Tidal HiFi quality.
You can check out the full list of the smart devices and HiFi systems that Tidal Supports on their site, and you can also use AirPlay and Chromecast. With any of these services, you will hear the higher quality audio better with good headphones. Here’s a nice option that is under $50.
Tidal HiFi vs Amazon Music HD Prices & Discounts
Amazon and Tidal both offer a range of pricing and you can save with Prime, as a student, a first responder or military member. Here’s a breakdown of the HiFi vs HD prices and plans. Amazon Music Ultra HD is included with HD.
|Price Per Month||Tidal HiFi||
Amazon Music HD
|Free Trial||30 Days||30 Days|
$14.99 ($12.99 with Prime)
|First Responder Plan||$12||NA|
Tidal offers a wider array of discounts based on who you are and what you do, but if you are an Amazon Prime subscriber ($119 a year) you save on Amazon Music HD and Ultra HD.
Apps, Devices & Experiences
When it comes to listening, you can use Amazon Music HD and Tidal HiFi on iPhone, Android, the web, desktop and the Apple TV.
For smart speakers, Amazon Music HD works best on the Echo products, specifically the Echo Studio if you want to hear the higher quality sound. You can use Amazon Music HD on Google devices, but the integration is limited.
Tidal HiFi works on Google, Nest, Sonos and Echo devices with deep integration into each of the speakers. If you use smart speakers outside of the Echo lineup, you may want to pick Tidal HiFi.
Amazon includes lyrics in the app for songs on Music HD, while Tidal does not offer in-app lyrics.
Tidal does stand out with exclusive music, music videos and access to special concerts as well as other artist access that isn’t available on Amazon Music HD. Explore those options with a free trial to see if they are worth the price.
Does Amazon Music HD or Tidal Sound Better?
Perhaps even more important than where you can play it and how much it costs, is what sounds better, Amazon Music HD or Tidal HiFi?
Opinions are split, and it comes down to your preferences. Most listeners feel that Tidal HiFi sounds warmer while Amazon Music HD has a better sense of space.
The best way to figure out if Amazon Music HD or Tidal sounds better is to do a free trial of each and listen on your equipment.
Which Should You Subscribe To?
Amazon Music HD is the best value if you are an Amazon Prime member and you use Echo devices for your smart speakers. Get a free Amazon Music HD trial
Tidal HiFi is the best option if you prefer the warmer sound profile, enjoy using other smart speakers and especially if you qualify for the numerous discounts. Get a free Tidal HiFi trial.
Try both out and see which one you like. If you want to skip the 30-day Tidal HiFi trial, you can pay $5 for 5 months of Tidal HiFi to see what all the fuss is about.
This article may contain affiliate links. Click here for more details.