Why does someone on welfare need an iPhone or a smartphone at all? This is a question we hear fairly regularly online and in person as people observe someone using an iPhone while checking out with WIC, food stamps or some other form of welfare. While it is a controversial subject, there are a number of important reasons that someone who is in need of public assistance owns and uses an iPhone or some other kind of smartphone. It is easy to judge someone else who needs help, but before passing judgement on the type of phone that someone is holding while they use food stamps or welfare there are plenty of factors to keep in mind.
We spoke to individuals who’ve been in that situation, social workers and employers to find out why people need a smartphone, and why people who are on some form of welfare might need a smartphone more desperately than people who aren’t on welfare. We found that for many people on welfare, a phone isn’t a luxury; it’s a lifeline to a new job, training, contact with family and access to many of the services they’ll need to get off welfare and back into the working world.
The most important thing to remember about someone who is on public assistance while using an iPhone is that circumstances can change very quickly. Just because someone loses a job or needs help doesn’t mean they can get out of a multi-year contract for their iPhone or smartphone without a hefty cancellation fee that they cannot afford right now.
It is also just as possible that this is a completely paid off iPhone that has no cellular service but can still take calls and send emails when connected to WiFi.
Here is a closer look at why you shouldn’t judge someone on welfare with an iPhone or smartphone of any kind.
Melanie Carlson, a social worker who works with victims of domestic violence and those experiencing homelessness shares why a smartphone is an essential tool for anyone, but maybe even more important for someone facing these problems.
“Many low-income clients need smart phones for the same reasons higher income people do, but their need is far greater. Primarily, because they don’t often have computers in the home and rely on smartphones to connect to the web.”
Carlson argues that when we evaluate the worthiness of access to the Internet and technology based on income, race, gender ethnicity and other factors we marginalize people. Carlson refers us to a report on the digital divide that is incredibly important in finding a job and simply living in the current environment.
“The digital divide is typically proposed as a lack of information and communication technology (ICT) access. The underlying warrant framing the digital divide as a “problem”—that information is a public good—positions information technology/access as a resource that all must have but some “have-not.”
Carlson sums it up best in her conclusion to Gotta Be Mobile, stating, “Internet access is a human right.”
One common thread noticed when discussing the need for people on welfare or foodstamps to have a smartphone of some kind is that many times this is a device that does not include a cellular connection. While working with people in need, Carlson shared the following information about why a smartphone is arguably more essential to a person experiencing homelessness or in need than it is to someone who also owns a laptop and other devices.
“My clients often didn’t even have data plans on their smartphones, but would go down the street to McDonalds and use their free Wi-Fi. My clients often experienced a lot of housing instability, which contributed to frequent address changes or a lot of house hopping. A common way to keep their lives in order was to maintain the same phone number and e-mail address. Increasingly, not only are most job applications online (of which low paid jobs often require lengthy personality tests), but also most states are moving towards centralizing the administration of benefits through online databases.”
This is just a portion of why everyone needs access to the conveniences and advantages of owning a smartphone. We also learned about other reasons a smartphone is an essential tool for anyone to own.
- Weather Alerts
- Active Shooter Alerts
- School Closings
- Real Time Public Transportation Information
The need to connect to the Internet does not stop when we lose a job or lose a home. In these situations the loss of connectivity is an even bigger issue in recovering from a downturn.
Even though selling a used iPhone might raise some cash, this pales in comparison to the benefits that connectivity, even limited to public WiFi, delivers to users.
Employers are also very vocal about the need to connect with potential job seekers. Steve Silberberg of Fitpacking Weight Loss Backpacking Adventures, tells Gotta Be Mobile,
“As an employer, I want to hire the most skilled individuals possible. A person who doesn’t have a smart phone (or doesn’t know how to use one) is less skilled than someone who does. Furthermore, much of my business correspondence is electronic, so it’s vital for someone who may not have a computer to have a way of electronically communicating via smartphone. Without a smartphone a person trying to improve their situation is crippled.”
“Finding and keeping a job is extremely challenging in today’s world especially for those who don’t have consistent living situation. Employers are less likely to hire or continue to employ people they can’t reach reliably via phone and now via text message.
For those who can only work part-time a smart phone would allow them to earn money through services like care.com and taskrabbit.com that connect individuals with small jobs. The phone also would provide access to free online job training from coursera.com and codeacademy.com as a way to rise out of an impoverished situation. And with new employers services like GetSling.com promising the ability to schedule your non-desk employees seamlessly, a job may be out of reach if you can’t afford a smartphone.
There are so many essentials to securing a keeping a job including the basics of reliable transportation, inexpensive food, and appropriate clothing but if freely available a smartphone could be a powerful tool for those struggling to make ends meet to get educated, find jobs, and stay employed.”
David Bakke of MoneyCrashers outlines another important aspect of why someone on public assistance needs a smartphone, and why they might have a relatively new iPhone. Bakke tells Gotta Be Mobile, “close to 20% of those who receive welfare via the Aid to Families with Dependent Children program use it for fewer than seven months, meaning that their situation which requires assistance is usually only temporary.”
When it comes to finding a job, a smartphone is an essential tool and more so for someone who might not have a laptop and home internet connection. Bakka explains, “According to Pew Research, households which earn less than $30,000 each year use their mobile device to look for information on jobs at double the rate of those who earn $75,000 or more, and are over four times as likely to send in a job application via their smartphone.”
After speaking with experts and employers it’s clear that a smartphone is an essential tool for everyone, even if they are currently homeless or receiving financial aid to make ends meet after a sudden change in their financial situation.